Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Migration from Windows Live Photogallery (reusing face detection information)

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Migration from Windows Live Photogallery (reusing face detection information)

    Hello everyone,

    I have a passion for taking photos, like so many of you here in this forum (nice to meet you all ). Meanwhile I have around 170.000 personal photos and my use case is very simple: most of my photos I take are from family, friends and our various pets throughout the years. When I get the question from a friend or family member: "hey, can you show me photos with us together" I want to be able to quickly do this in a very simple and fast way. As I have a bad memory (when did I do what and who was around years ago) I am tagging all my photos.

    Until 2021 I was using Windows Live Photogallery (WLP) since its launch due to the simplicity and the face detection capabilities. The best part I loved about it was that it embedded the tags and the faces detected directly in the files. Throughout the years when I switched PCs I did not need to move any database. I just started WLP and it simply read all data again from the files. Surprisingly WLP handles very well a high number of photos.

    But technology evolved and I encountered several limitations recently: hi-res photos are sometimes not read, .heic extensions are not known etc. This made me look for another software (hard decision after so many years). I read a lot about various software and the capabilities. I tested Abobe and while I am a big fan of Photoshop for editing. But Lightroom just does not fit for me. I feels awkward when trying to use (compared to the simplicity of WLP). Also forcing people to purchase a subscription for an on-premises software is even more strage. After Í read the other day that they suddenly disabled the face detection capabilities for the old version (even though customers have purchased it), I realized that Adobe is not an option anymore. Many other software providers focus on a lot of features for sharing photos on different social networks. Great, but not my focus area.

    AcdSee was a natural selection. I used AcdSee long time before WLP and it worked very nice. But I missed the face detection options. During the years I saw detection capabilities being introduced in more and more software, including AcdSee. It's, from the usability perspective, still not there yet, where I would like, but it's ok and works fine. Once I get used to it I plan to provide more detailed feedback in case the AcdSee developers are looking for improvement ideas. Now comes the compatibility topic...

    How can I reuse the Face Detection data already saved by WLP in the files?

    I purchased ACDSee 2021 Pro and I started to build the database, first with a couple of hundred photos only. The face detection works great (better than WLP) but it's not able to read the data already saved by WLP in the file. I found this thread https://forum.acdsee.com/forum/main-...-in-file/page2 which is great and I'd like to know if AcdSee developers are planning any migration option from Windows Live Photogallery to AcdSee?

    The reason why I am asking this is following: if I let AcdSee to scan all my photos, detect the faces and embed the data in the files, I assume that this will lead to having the face information 2 times in the files. While this is not so bad now, we do not know how the standards will evolve in the future and I assume that at one point, this double information will backfire. Also I see that AcdSee has migration tools for Lightroom.

    @ACDSee dev team: if you are interested in collaborating, I can gladly invest some time to help test this. It could enhance ACDSee's capabilities and help a lot of people out there.

    @ACDSee BDMs: IMHO having a tool which converts the face data saved by Windows Live Photogallery in the way AcdSee is saving it in the files would be a great way to attract new ACDSee customers and it would be an important positive sign for the entire community that ACDSee is listening to the customer voice.

    Thank you

  • #2
    There is some information about converting Microsoft Windows Live Photo Gallery face regions metadata to the standard Metadata Working Group format in the ExifTool forum. It could perhaps be worth looking at using ExifTool to batch convert the WLPG format metadata to the XMP regions format that ACDSee uses for its face metadata.

    Comment

    Working...
    X